Almost all coating problems are caused by design for manufacture (DFM) problems with the part geometry. What looks to be a simple drawing can cause massive problems once it has been coated. The majority of coating problems are found before the part reaches the finishing shop. This article outlines the major design features which could cause problems with coating.
Blind Holes And Pockets
Closed-end holes – Blind Holes / Closed Pockets. Trapped air within closed-end features can cause patchy coating formation. Introduce a small drain/vent hole where close-end features are not critical to part design.
So, these are design issues which need to be addressed before the part is released for finishing and therefore are best sorted out at the design stage as good design for manufacture practice (DFM) by the engineering designer.
Sharp Corners And Edges
Sharp Corners and Edges. Sharp external corners on a part can cause a number of problems. For plating type processes sharp corners can cause the current density to be concentrated at the corner resulting in an over thick deposit on that corner compared to the surrounding flat areas. For anodising type processes sharp corners can result in the oxide layer being of uneven thickness with the edges being of much thinner section than the rest of the surface and thus more susceptible to damage.
An added edge radius of 0.5mm or so (as used on concrete finishes for wear resistance) would also avoid problems with other Surface Treatments where a sharp edge creates localized high current density or problems with oxide growth in anodizing processes.
Deep Narrow Slots
Narrow recessed features, deep in relation to their width, can be difficult to fill and to load onto a coating rack. Coating thickness on such features can vary greatly from the entry point to the far end of the recess. In the worst case coating to only the very base of such a recess may be impossible.
Where the design is not to be altered widen the slot to allow for the free flow of solution. Clearly flag on the design drawings features that need to be racked in special ways or which need special anode placement.
Threaded Holes And Bores
Threads and holes can be difficult for coating processes to get into. The coating can build up in thickness in these features and cause problems with fit such as making a nut not to fit in the standard nut class.
Determine if a thread needs to be masked off to keep it bare metal, or allow for a specific thread class to allow for coating build-up. This needs to be specified by the designer, as an unspecified hole will be treated by the metal finisher as any other feature and so risk being poorly finished.
Sudden Changes In Thickness
Parts of large changes in thickness (tapering instead of sharp steps) are also not the easiest for plating and thermal treatment processes. Current distributions are not uniform and can cause uneven heating in processes depending on heat.
By gently tapering thick to thin sections, coating consistency can be improved. Even outside of metal finishing, controlling the thickness of surface layers is of importance. National Highways’ specifications for road surface dressings are a good example, since roads with a mix of thick and thin sections wear at different rates.
Welds Joints And Mixed Metals
Dissimilar metals welded together have weld porosity which can contain plating solution or other surface finishes cleaning solutions. These can then seep out of the weld at a later date causing staining or even blistering on the finished coating. Also, the galvanic effect between two different metals can affect the even deposition of a coating to a joint.
Flag the issue of Sharp Edges & Corners (as described above), as well as other features such as Slots, Threaded Holes and Sharp Changes in Thickness on your drawings and notify your finishing company of their presence before your parts are finished.
Surface Finish Before Treatment
A thin coat follows the surface of the base material on which it is applied, so (apparently) minor features of the surface of a part before treatment, such as machining marks, burrs or even millscale on cast parts can reveal themselves as shallow ridges or as flakes in the coat which flake off.
Typically, the surface finish before treatment is of greater importance than the surface finish after treatment. Unless specifically stated otherwise on the drawing, all parts should be treated as if they are to be plated. Industry standards for surface preparation of substrates prior to coating exist to help ensure surfaces are clean and of the correct smoothness prior to application of a coating.
Getting It Right Early
These factors can affect Surface Treatments but be covered by noting them on a drawing before parts are finished and sent to a surface treatment shop.
Checking your drawings for these critical details before sending parts to be surface treated will save hours of rework to strip and re-finish already machined parts.



